India approves massive barrage upstream
Hydel plant to dry up the Meghna
SHAHIDUL ISLAM CHOWDHURY
India is all set to
build a hydroelectric power plant, a massive barrage
inclusive, upstream of a major river system of Bangladesh that
could inflict on its downstream neighbours economic,
ecological and human catastrophes.
And
while experts and relevant officials at the Ministry of Water
Resources fear the repercussions of the mega-project could be
debilitating, the government has adopted a familiar position
of preferring to remain uninformed — because they ‘have not
been officially notified’ by the Indian
government.
The Central Electricity
Authority (CEA) of India, in the first week of this month,
approved the final techno-economic clearance (TEC) of the
controversial 1,500 Megawatt Tipaimukh Hydroelectric
Project.
Tipaimukh is located in the
north-eastern Indian state of Assam, close to the Bangladesh
border near Karimganj in Sylhet.
The
plant and its accompanying barrage is set to be built on the
river Borak, which divides into two streams as it enters
Bangladesh — the rivers Surma and
Kushiara.
The mighty Meghna originates at
the confluence of the Surma and the
Kushiara.
Experts in Bangladesh have
expressed their apprehensions about the project that is sure
to block the flow the country’s major riverine network in the
north-east and have further consequences
downstream.
They claim that it could hit
the country fatally, and in no less a magnitude than the
Farakka Barrage across the Ganges to the north-west of
Bangladesh.
“After completion of the
project, Bangladesh would get less water in three rivers —
Meghna, Surma and Kushiara,” Quamrul Islam Siddiqui, president
of the Institution of Engineers and chairman of the Global
Water Partnership, Bangladesh chapter, told New Age on
Sunday.
“After Farakka, the Tipaimukh
could spell another disaster for Bangladesh,” he
said.
Bangladesh and India have been at
loggerheads over water sharing since 1974, when India
completed the Farakka Barrage, diverting crucial dry-season
flows into Indian irrigation
canals.
Bangladesh blames the barrage for
dried-up fields, diseases and the salt poisoning of the vast
Sundarban mangrove swamps in the Ganges
delta.
Despite such a pronounced threat
to the ecology, economy and way of life, the government seems
least bothered to either officially lodge a complaint with
India or develop mechanisms to tackle the danger
posed.
“The Indian government has not
informed Bangladesh about the Tipaimukh project,” State
Minister for Water Resources Goutam Chakrabarty told New Age
on Monday. “Therefore we are not in a position to officially
respond to the issue.”
A source in the
Joint Rivers Commission (JRC) told New Age on Sunday, “We
unofficially requested our counterpart in India to give
information about the Tipaimukh project. But they did not
respond to our request.”
Some experts
belive that even though the project has already been given the
final go-ahead, there is still scope for negotiations between
the two neighbours on the issue.
“Bangladesh could not stop the commissioning of the Tipaimukh
project. But the government can attempt to find out how the
project would operate during the rainy and dry seasons and
negotiate to ensure the flow of the rivers,” Dr Ainun Nishat,
environmentalist and country director of IUCN Bangladesh, told
New Age on Sunday.
The CEA accorded the
final TEC for the Rs 51638.3 million project on July 2, after
getting the final clearance and no-objection certificate from
Mizoram the same day.
NEEPCO, the
project-implementing authority, has begun the process for
floating international tenders to undertake the Tipaimukh
project.
Contracts would be awarded by
March 2004. The project works, in 6 phases, are slated to be
completed by 2011. The first unit, with capacity of generating
250MW electricity, would be completed within 82 months of
awarding the contract.
Earlier, the
project was delayed after the Manipur State Assembly had put
up objections. The objections were withdrawn after NEEPCO
agreed to provide Rs 2,500 million for setting up protection
schemes in the project area.
Out of the
total project cost, Rs 1,000 million is earmarked for national
highway diversion, and another Rs 2,000 million for flood
mitigation.
Of the total electricity to
be produced by the plant, 11 percent and 1 percent would be
provided free to Manipur and Mizoram respectively as
royalty.
Sources at the water resources
ministry in Dhaka said that there are no international laws
about multi-riparian rivers. But the convention is that an
upper-riparian country would inflict ‘nothing damaging’ on its
lower-riparian neighbour.
Here, at the
Tipaimukh instance, the convention is not being practised,
they said.