|
Published On: 2008-11-14
Point Counterpoint
What we can do
S. Nazrul Islam
BANGLADESH is likely to be one of the worst victims of climate
change. Due to its low elevation, large parts of the country
may get inundated as a result of sea level rise, forcing
millions of people into an exodus. Melting of the Himalayan
glaciers may dry up the Himalayan rivers completely during the
winter months. At the same time, excessive precipitation
during the summer may aggravate flooding.
These radical changes in the weather pattern may disrupt the
country's agriculture, economy, ecology, and life in general.
Further temperature rise may cause new problems of disease and
epidemic in this tropical country. All in all, climate change
poses a serious calamity of probably catastrophic proportions
for Bangladesh.
It is ironic that Bangladesh is going to be one of the worst
victims of climate change when she is one of the countries
least responsible for this change. It is the greenhouse gas
emission (GHG) by the developed countries over the last 250
years (since the Industrial Revolution) that has resulted in
the current high atmospheric concentration level of CO2,
causing the climate change.
It is, therefore, the responsibility of the developed
countries to arrest climate change by drastically reducing
their GHG emissions. Bangladesh needs to raise a strong voice
in international forums, urging developed countries and other
large emitters to reduce their GHG emissions.
Unfortunately, even if mitigation measures get momentum in the
coming years, some climate change has become inevitable,
because the high GHG concentration already reached has set off
certain processes that are now irreversible, at least in the
short run. Second, reductions in GHG emission (under the Kyoto
Protocol, and the Protocol that will eventually replace it)
will occur in phases, so it will take some time before the
atmospheric GHG concentration level stabilises and, hopefully,
starts to decrease.
This inevitability of climate change to a certain degree in
the near future implies that alongside demanding mitigation at
the international level, Bangladesh also needs to work toward
adaptation and mitigation at home.
So far, the climate change issue has elicited in government
and non-government circles mainly enthusiasm about seeking
financial assistance from donor countries for various
"adaptation" purposes. Thus, Bangladesh has participated
eagerly in various international and bilateral conferences and
has pleaded for financial help and compensation.
What is, however, more important is to look inward and find
out what the country itself can do to confront the climate
change challenge. Unless a national vision is developed
through domestic introspection, outside money may not be that
effective.
Bangladesh's experience with water development efforts
illustrates this lesson very clearly. After spending millions
of dollars and about twenty percent of national development
budget each year on various water development projects for
almost half a century, the country is witnessing aggravation
of flooding and spread of water-logging. It is important for
Bangladesh to avoid a repetition of this sorry experience with
regard to her efforts to confront climate change effects.
The experience so far does not seem to be that promising in
this regard. Bangladesh's response is being shaped largely by
foreign advice and funding, and incorrect ideas are finding
their way into that. For example, Bangladesh Climate Change
Strategy and Action Plan (BCCSAP), the document that the
government recently prepared for participation in the
"UK-Bangladesh Climate Change Conference: Bangladesh Facing
the Challenge," held in London in September, puts a lot of
emphasis on embankments and polders as adaptation measures.
Yet, the geological history of the Bengal delta shows that
sedimentation caused by the Himalayan rivers is the most
important bulwark that this delta can have against the rising
sea level caused by global warming. Embankments are harmful to
this process because they obstruct the sedimentation process.
Also likelihood of the Himalayan rivers having excessive flow
in summer and becoming completely dry in winter makes it even
more imperative for Bangladesh to make it easier for the river
flow to spread across the floodplains in the summer and to be
able to retain much of this overflow for use in the winter.
BCCSAP's emphasis on embankments is, therefore, erroneous,
because embankments cordon off floodplains from river channels
and thus obstruct the river flow from spreading across
floodplains during the summer and in turn deprive the
floodplains from sedimentation and other beneficial effects of
river overflow.
The climate change challenge, therefore, shows that Bangladesh
needs to abandon the current cordon approach to rivers and to
adopt open, ecological approach that preserves and enhances
organic connection between river channels and adjoining
floodplains. The above example concerning approach to rivers
shows that outside financial assistance will not be effective
unless Bangladesh sets its domestic policies correct.
What is, therefore, important is to conduct a national
introspection and find out what is wrong with domestic
policies in different sectors and how these can be changed in
order to confront the challenges posed by climate change.
Bangladesh Poribesh Andolon (Bapa) and Bangladesh Environment
Network (Ben) have taken initiative to hold a national
conference on "Climate Change and Bangladesh's Domestic
Tasks," in order to facilitate national introspection and
develop a national vision regarding how to prepare the country
better for the climate change challenge. It will be held on in
Dhaka.
The conference will bring together climate change experts from
both inside and outside Bangladesh. Bangladesh has significant
domestic expertise with regard to climate change issues. Many
Bangladeshi scholars have contributed to the IPCC and other
international climate change discussions and negotiation
processes.
Meanwhile, many Bangladeshi scholars working abroad have also
developed significant expertise on the climate change issue.
The conference plans to combine the domestic expertise with
the expertise offered by diaspora Bangladesh to formulate a
better national response to the climate change challenge.
However, Bapa and Ben believe that environmental problems,
including that of climate change, cannot be solved through
discussions of experts alone. The solution requires wide
participation of the public, including political parties and
their leaders. After all, it is the latter who are expected to
provide leadership to Bangladesh's efforts to survive through
climate change.
The conference will, therefore, invite representatives for
various segments of the society, including political parties.
The conference will also enlist participation of
representatives of local communities of various parts of the
country likely to be more affected by climate change so that
they can inform from their first hand experience about various
changes that are occurring in their respective areas, from the
coastal region of the south to the haor areas of the north.
It is expected that, through a shared discussion of experts
and public representatives from various cross-sections of the
society and various parts of the country, it will be possible
to develop a national vision and a concrete strategy about how
Bangladesh can confront the climate change challenge.
The country is supposed to have an election and an elected
government soon. It may be hoped that the discussions and
recommendations of the conference will prove helpful for the
new government in charting the future course of the nation
with regard to the climate change issue.
Bapa and Ben are inviting all who have expertise and interest
in the climate change issue to take an active part in the
conference of January 2. Let's hope that the climate change
challenge will summon the best of the nation in order to
ensure that the nation survives!
[For further details about the conference, please contact Dr.
M. A. Matin, BAPA General Secretary (e-mail: memory14@agni.com
). Those abroad, please contact Dr. Dipen Bhattacharya,
University of California, Riverside, CA, USA (E-mail: tishan2@yahoo.com
)]
S. Nazrul Islam is Coordinator, Bangladesh Environment Network (BEN).
E-mail: s_n_islam@yahoo.com
|
|